When your success bothers someone

In short: English has a phrase for what happens to some people when they succeed: tall poppy syndrome. The poppy that grows taller than the rest of the field gets cut down so the field stays level. Studies of New Zealand entrepreneurs show that many have felt it, and that some responded by keeping a low profile. Studies of women show that their success can draw dislike more easily, and that other women sometimes take part in it. The data on online abuse against women is real, but no study that I could verify links the whole chain, from women entrepreneurs to social media. Below is what is known, what is not, and what you can do.

Table of Contents

What tall poppy syndrome is

Picture an entrepreneur who announces on social media that her business has turned its first profit. She gets congratulations and, among them, a few comments that cut: “We all know who opened doors for you,” “Lucky you,” “Let’s see how long it lasts.” None of it can be proven false. What stays is a bitter taste and a question: will I post next time?

(The scene is imagined. The researchers below describe situations from the same family.)

Tall poppy syndrome means that people are attacked, resented, disliked, criticised or cut down because of their achievements or success. That is the wording used by the organisation Women of Influence in the study discussed below.

The phrase comes from Australian and New Zealand English. The researcher B. Peeters analysed it in a 2004 article and tied it to Australian egalitarianism: the idea that nobody should think themselves above others, which can turn into scrutiny of those who stand out.

What studies say about entrepreneurs

Kirkwood (2007). Jodyanne Kirkwood, of the University of Otago in New Zealand, interviewed 40 entrepreneurs about the syndrome. The study appeared in the Journal of Management & Organization. More than half said they had experienced it. They responded by keeping a low profile, not telling everyone they own a business, and not showing off their wealth.

The conclusions in the abstract are more serious than they sound:

  • the syndrome may discourage people from starting a business;
  • people who have had a business failure may be reluctant to try again;
  • some entrepreneurs may deliberately limit the growth of their business so as not to attract attention.

In other words, it is not just a personal hurt. It can change how people decide to run their business.

University of Auckland (2022). Jo Kirkwood and Professor Rod McNaughton ran a survey in which nearly 300 people shared their experiences. Participants described self-doubt, depression, anxiety, lost opportunities and, in some cases, leaving the country. One detail matters for our topic: cutting remarks about success came most often from colleagues, face to face. Social media came a distant second. The researchers recommend starting with the people closest to us and reframing success so that others share and amplify it rather than resent it.

Worth remembering: tall poppy syndrome does not mainly happen online. Online can be part of it, not all of it.

What studies say about women

Two kinds of evidence show up here: social-psychology experiments and a large survey with limits.

The experiments. Heilman and colleagues (2004), in the Journal of Applied Psychology, ran three experiments with 242 participants. A successful woman in a job seen as typically male was rated less likeable and more personally derogated than an equally successful man. The effect appeared only when the field was distinctly male, and it had consequences for evaluations and reward recommendations.

A later study, Heilman and Okimoto (2007), showed the penalty eased when the woman was also shown to have “communal” traits, meaning care and cooperation. The authors read this as a violation of expectations about how a woman should behave.

Women among themselves. Parks-Stamm, Heilman and Hearns (2008), in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, ran two studies. Both men and women penalised the successful woman. But when female participants were prevented from doing so, only their own self-rated competence dropped, not that of male participants. The authors read the derogation as self-protection against a threatening comparison. When women were given positive feedback about their own potential, their negative reactions towards the successful woman weakened.

This does not mean women are “jealous.” It means a psychological mechanism can be influenced, and an environment that tells women there is room for them to succeed too reduces the attacks.

The Women of Influence survey (2023). The Canadian organisation Women of Influence surveyed 4,710 women in 103 countries between 9 January and 10 February 2023. Results:

  • 86.8% had experienced the syndrome at work;
  • common forms: achievements downplayed (77%), being left out of meetings or ignored (72.4%), being undermined (70.7%), someone else taking credit (66.1%);
  • effects: more stress (85.6%), a negative impact on mental health (73.8%), lower self-confidence (66.2%);
  • 67.8% had looked for another role, and 50% had left a role;
  • 60.5% believe they would be penalised for being seen as ambitious;
  • men in leadership were more likely to penalise or undermine women, while women were more likely to cut down peers.

The limits of this survey matter: the questionnaire went to contacts in the organisation’s own database and was shared on social media, so the sample is self-selected, no margin of error is reported, the study was not peer reviewed, and the results are about the workplace, not about women entrepreneurs or online settings. I cite it as an indication, not as proof.

Online: what is known

I found no peer-reviewed research that explicitly links tall poppy syndrome, women entrepreneurs and social media. There is, however, data on cyber violence against women in general, and it helps with context.

European Union (EIGE, Eurostat). The EU survey on gender-based violence (EU-GBV, coordinated by Eurostat, 2020-2024) measured, among other things, repeated online abuse that causes fear, alarm or distress (cyber stalking). Lifetime experience among women ranges from 7.4% in Romania to 18% in Sweden. Among women aged 18-24, it is 23%. The figures do not say why Romania sits at the low end: it may be reality, or a difference in how people report or recognise it.

EU Agency for Fundamental Rights (FRA, 2014). The survey of 42,000 women in 28 member states found that 11% had received unwelcome advances on social websites or sexually explicit emails or text messages, and among women aged 18-29, 20%. In addition, 18% had been stalked since the age of 15.

European Parliament (IPOL study, 2023). A study by authors at Dublin City University, commissioned by the FEMM committee, describes a silencing effect. It cites a 2017 Amnesty International report: 76% of respondents said online abuse changed how they use social media, and 32% had stopped posting altogether. The study also notes that, in politics, women deliberately make themselves less visible to avoid hostile reactions. It warns that data on cyber violence in the EU is limited by how member states collect it.

Women entrepreneurs (Cherie Blair Foundation for Women, 2024). A UK foundation surveyed 2,870 women entrepreneurs in 96 low- and middle-income countries in November-December 2024. Results:

  • 57% had experienced at least one form of online harassment through social media;
  • 36% do not publish their full name on their business profiles, 41% do not use pictures of themselves, 59% do not post videos of themselves;
  • reasons given: fear of harassment, unsolicited messages and reputational damage.

The sample is a convenience sample, so it does not represent all women entrepreneurs in those countries, and the survey covers low- and middle-income countries, not EU member states. The figures are indicative, but they show something clear: harassment does not stay a mood. It changes what women entrepreneurs show of themselves. Kirkwood found the same pattern among New Zealand entrepreneurs: a lower profile.

What is not known

I say plainly what is missing, so that nobody thinks we know more than we do:

  • There is no study (that I could verify) that is peer reviewed and links tall poppy syndrome, women entrepreneurs and attacks on social media.
  • There is no data on Romania for women entrepreneurs and online harassment as a distinct group.
  • The New Zealand studies show that attacks come mostly face to face, not online. We cannot say that the phenomenon is “growing on social media.”
  • The Women of Influence survey is self-selected and about the workplace.
  • The Heilman experiments are laboratory studies in which participants read described situations. They show a mechanism, not how often it happens in real life.

What it looks like in practice

The Women of Influence survey offers useful vocabulary. Its most common forms, moved into entrepreneurship, would look roughly like this:

  • the achievement downplayed: “You’re lucky,” “It was easy for you,” “Anyone could have done it”;
  • exclusion: you are not invited to groups, events or conversations where decisions are made;
  • undermining: someone questions your competence in public without arguments;
  • taking credit: your idea or work appears under someone else’s name.

Online, the same forms can show up as comments, being ignored, your work shared without credit, or private messages. Not every critical comment is an attack. Criticism of your work (a price, a quality, a method) can be answered with arguments. An attack on you as a person (who you are, how you look, “who do you think you are”) leaves nothing to discuss.

What you can do

The research offers no recipe. What follows is practical advice, not findings from the studies, except for the last point. I am not a psychologist or a lawyer, and the text does not replace the support of a specialist.

  • Name it. Knowing that the pattern has a name and has been studied helps you not take it as a personal flaw.
  • Keep evidence. Screenshots with the date and account name, before you block or delete.
  • Do not get into public fights. One calm reply, or none. You can restrict or block the account and report the comment on the platform.
  • Tell criticism from attack. Answer the first, ignore the second.
  • Talk to someone. A colleague, a mentor or a group you trust. Keeping it all to yourself makes it easier for the attack to convince you the problem is you.
  • If you are threatened, contact the police with your evidence ready.
  • Choose consciously how much you show. Hiding your name or photo is a legitimate protective choice, and the entrepreneurs surveyed by the Cherie Blair Foundation do it. It has a cost, though: Kirkwood shows that some entrepreneurs limit growth so as not to be noticed. It is better to choose on purpose than out of fear.
  • For the people around you: celebrate other people’s success visibly. This is the recommendation of the Auckland researchers, and the easiest to put into practice.

Conclusion

Tall poppy syndrome is not a story about envy in general. It is a social mechanism described by linguists, studied among entrepreneurs and, in social psychology, among women who succeed. What we know for sure is that some entrepreneurs change their behaviour to avoid attention, that successful women can be penalised for their success, and that online harassment against women is measured in Europe. What we do not know yet is how often all of this happens together. If you have been through it, you are not alone and you are not too sensitive. Tell us in the comments how it looked in your case, without names or personal data.

Sources and further reading

About the author

Brîndușa Maria, Senior Software Test Analyst, ISTQB® Certified Tester Advanced Level Test Analyst (CTAL-TA). I write about how to recognize online scams. LinkedIn

Note: this article is based on my research and professional experience. I used artificial intelligence tools for drafting and editing.

📢 Share the knowledge, stay safe! 🔒✨ Use the share buttons below and help others stay safe online. The more we know about online scams, the better protected we are! 🚀💙

Leave a Reply